The New Green Energy Giants Challenging Exxon and BP

Source: By Katherine Blunt and Sarah McFarlane, Wall Street Journal • Posted: Sunday, December 13, 2020

Three utilities that invested early in wind and solar power now rival major oil companies in market value. Can they continue to dominate as the world’s shift to renewable energy accelerates?

A decade ago, NextEra, Iberdrola IBDRY -0.85% and Enel ENEL -1.96% were sleepy regional utilities with little name recognition.

Now they are fast-growing giants with market values rivaling the likes of oil majors Exxon Mobil Corp. XOM -0.48% and BP BP -1.70% PLC, thanks to their early all-in bets on wind and solar farms.

And still, many people have never heard of them.

Their early lead in the global transition away from oil has put these companies on track to become the major energy companies of the coming decades—the “green energy majors.” But they now face the threat of increased competition as some of the oil titans that have traditionally dominated the energy industry diversify into wind and solar power.

Sand is screened during construction to expand the Beinn an Tuirc Windfarm on the Kintyre peninsula in Scotland. Iberdrola is the world’s second largest renewable energy generator outside of China.

If the green majors are nervous about a coming clash, they aren’t showing it. NextEra Energy Inc. NEE 0.71% Chief Executive James Robo dismissed the idea that oil majors in the U.S. and Europe posed a competitive threat at an investor conference this fall, saying that the companies’ green projects were among the worst he had seen.

“I don’t worry about the oil majors at all,” he told the audience. “If I have 100 things I worry about at night, it’s not even on the top 100.” Mr. Robo declined to be interviewed.

For now, NextEra, Enel SpA and Iberdrola SA are Wall Street darlings, after Spain’s Iberdrola and Italy’s Enel became global builders of green energy projects, while NextEra became America’s largest generator of wind and solar power.

Each of the companies has seen its share price soar in recent months as investors bet on their ability to lead the transition to a lower-carbon future with massive investments in renewable energy, battery storage and improvements to the electric grid.

That transition is expected to accelerate in the U.S. under President-elect Joe Biden, who has promised to focus on climate change, and within the European Union and China, where ambitious carbon-reduction efforts are under way.

Enel and Iberdrola have outlined plans to substantially expand their portfolios of renewable-energy projects over the next decade with about $170 billion in collective investments. NextEra, which hasn’t disclosed a long-term spending plan, expects to have invested $60 billion in renewable energy projects between 2019 and 2022.

Still, analysts caution that increased competition within the renewables industry could reduce profit margins for the most established players.

“Oil companies entering the renewables market will need to accept lower returns on projects initially to gain market share, and this is going to result in a reduction in margins across the board,” said Fernando Garcia of RBC Capital Markets.

Workers help guide part of a wind turbine at the Beinn an Tuirc wind farm in Scotland.

Already, Denmark’s Ørsted A/S, a company formerly known as DONG Energythat focused on oil and gas, has transitioned into a leading player in offshore wind projects. BP is planning a big shift too: It says it will increase its clean-energy investments in coming years as it dramatically scales back oil and gas production.

However, the coronavirus pandemic has decimated demand for fossil fuels this year, briefly turning U.S. crude prices negative and forcing the oil industry to lay off thousands of workers and slash spending. That has sapped the oil giants of much of their financial strength, making it harder for them to quickly transitioninto renewables projects, which require large upfront investment in order to reap steady returns over a longer period.

While big oil companies once reported double-digit returns on invested capital—in the heady days prior to 2014, when crude oil prices last topped $100 a barrel, some topped 20% annually, according to FactSet—the big renewables players have been winning the race of late with slow and steady single-digit returns.

“There is no better example than 2020 to show how extremely different the risk profiles are,” said Bernstein analyst Meike Becker.

Iberdrola, Enel and NextEra have taken different paths to morph from humdrum utilities into green growth companies.

Originally an Italian utility, Enel was actually later than some others to home in on wind and solar. Two years after forming its renewable development arm, Enel Green Power, the company sold about a third of it in 2010 to pay down corporate debt. Enel then focused on trying to build nuclear plants in Italy before citizens there rejected that plan.

But Enel’s current chief executive, Francesco Starace, then the head of that green unit, said he recognized that wind and solar power had the potential to become competitive in the broader energy market as costs fell. The unit focused on developing projects in regions without large subsidies or incentives to show investors that they could stand on their own.

“At the time, this sounded like blasphemy or idiocy,” Mr. Starace said in an interview. “But we did it stubbornly, and kept doing it, and eventually this prediction of ours became true.”

Mr. Starace became Enel’s CEO in 2014, and promptly repurchased the portion of Enel Green Power that had earlier been sold. He also reoriented Enel to pursue projects that could be completed within three years to account for the pace of technological change. That pretty much eliminated nuclear and coal plants, as well as large hydroelectric projects, leaving wind and solar farms in the mix.

Enel is now the world’s largest renewable energy producer outside China, with an €84 billion market value, equal to about $102 billion, and projects in 32 countries. The company has a large presence in the U.S. and has developed wind and solar farms in remote areas in countries including Zambia and Chile. The company plans to spend about €70 billion, equivalent to $85 billion, to nearly triple its generation capacity in the coming decade, which it expects will give it around 4% of the global market.

Iberdrola, initially a domestic Spanish utility, was an early pioneer of renewables. It started in 2001, when the company unveiled a plan to expand internationally and invest in clean energy sources to help meet growing global demand for power.

It tapped Ignacio Galán to spearhead the strategy as CEO at a time when wind and solar power were still hugely expensive relative to other electricity sources. The company had historically focused on building hydroelectric and nuclear plants, as well as some coal- and gas-fired ones.

Iberdrola has expanded into renewables in part by aggressively buying up smaller players with attractive growth prospects. In October, it agreed to pay $4.3 billion for New Mexico-based electricity company PNM Resources Inc. —its eighth deal this year. It plans to invest heavily in the U.S., where the company is third in renewables generation capacity behind NextEra and Berkshire Hathaway Energy, a unit of Warren Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway Inc.

Former NextEra Energy executive Armando Pimentel and former U.S. Interior Secretary Sally Jewell flip a ceremonial power switch during a dedication ceremony for a new solar farm in Desert Center, Calif. in 2015. Despite its rapid growth, NextEra has largely flown under the radar. Photo: Marcus Yam//Los Angeles Times/Getty Images

Mr. Galán said in an interview that Iberdrola at first faced skepticism about its decision to focus on renewables, but now the tide has turned: The company’s value has multiplied by six on his watch to around €71 billion, or $86 billion, far exceeding his initial ambition to double its size.

“All we have been fighting for for 20 years, every person recognizes that was the right decision,” he said.

Iberdrola is now the world’s second largest renewable energy generator outside of China, with projects in 30 countries, including an offshore wind farm in the Baltic Sea and a wind and solar farm in Australia. It plans to spend €75 billion, equivalent to $91 billion, over the next five years to double its renewable power capacity.

Florida-based NextEra grew into America’s largest renewable energy producer by keeping debt levels low, capitalizing on federal tax subsidies available to help finance wind and solar projects around the country and reinvesting its profits to expand further.

Over time, it developed the size and scale needed to consistently underbid other companies in auctions to develop projects. It operates two Florida utilities and sells renewable energy output to others. It also operates electric transmission lines in the U.S. and Canada, as well as natural gas pipelines.

Despite its rapid growth, NextEra has largely flown under the radar. Some lawmakers in Washington and elsewhere didn’t know much about it until recently. The company several years ago launched a targeted effort to introduce itself so that its representatives wouldn’t have to start meetings with tedious explanations, according to a person familiar with the company’s strategy.

NextEra declined to comment. The company’s executives still rarely speak to the press.

Investors, however, have been eyeing NextEra for years. Its share price has roughly tripled over the past five years to reach a market value of $146 billion, and for the first time it briefly topped Exxon’s value this year in a watershed moment for renewables producers. Its project backlog totals 15,000 megawatts—an amount just larger than its current portfolio, built over two decades.

BP Capital Fund Advisors, a Dallas-based investment adviser that has historically focused on oil and gas, bought shares in NextEra in March as part of an effort to diversify with investments in renewables. The firm was founded by the late T. Boone Pickens, the oil industry magnate who took an interest in wind and solar power late in his career. He died last year.

“NextEra stands alone in terms of what it offers in exposure to the renewable theme,” said portfolio manager Ben Cook. “If you’re investing in energy now…that has to be part of the equation.”

Ørsted A/S, a company formerly known as DONG Energy that focused on oil and gas, has transitioned into a leading player in offshore wind projects, such as this one off the west coast of northern England. Photo: PAUL ELLIS/Agence France-Presse/Getty Images

Write to Katherine Blunt at and Sarah McFarlane at